The requisition comes in with the sole-source box ticked. Under it sits a paragraph from the requester. The equipment is specialized, the supplier knows our setup, and a switch would disrupt the lab. Procurement reads it, approves it and moves to the next one.
We think that box ends more negotiations than any supplier does. Most of the suppliers behind it are single-source by habit. Another firm could do the work. Nobody has asked one in years.
Two labels that get filed as one
Sole source means one supplier can meet the need. A patent can make that true. So can a proprietary interface, or an OEM part for a machine you already own. Single source means you picked one supplier from several and kept it.
The US government keeps these apart. Under FAR 6.302-1, a federal buyer can skip full competition when only one responsible source can meet the requirement. The justification has to be written down and approved before the award. Most companies use the same words with none of that discipline.
Inside a company, both labels land in the same box. Once there, they get the same treatment. Nobody runs an event. Nobody asks for a second quote.
The inherited sole source
Take a service contract for a lab analyzer. In 2021 the manufacturer was the only firm trained to service that model, and the requester said so. Since then, two regional firms have trained technicians on it. The justification on file still says what it said in 2021.
We call this the inherited sole source. The label was true once, or close to true. Each renewal copies the old paragraph forward, and the copy carries the old facts with it.
A category manager who has renewed that contract three times has read the paragraph three times. She has never had a reason to test it. The renewal shows up 60 days before the notice date with a new price attached. Checking the market looks like a project nobody has budget for.
The requester has reasons of their own. They know the incumbent's technician by name. A new supplier means training, a new contact and a risk that lands on them if it goes wrong. None of that appears in the paragraph, and all of it is real. We would put a number on those costs. Usually the number is smaller than the price gap.
So the paragraph wins again.
What the supplier sees
The supplier can tell how you buy. It sees no RFP, no competing quote and a renewal signed in the last week of the window. It sees the same thing every cycle. An account manager with a quota knows which renewals have never been tested, and those are the easiest numbers to hit.
It prices for that pattern. With no visible competitor, a supplier has no reason to sharpen its number. The price-increase letter asks for 6%, and you have nothing to set beside it.
We have argued before that suppliers price your switching cost. A sole-source label tells them the cost has no ceiling. In practice it may be six weeks of onboarding and one awkward call.
What one more quote is worth
Take a $600,000 a year contract up for a three-year renewal at a fixed price. The supplier asks for 6% more, so $636,000 a year. Suppose one credible quote from a second firm brings the incumbent back to flat. That is $36,000 a year, or $108,000 over the term.
You do not have to switch to collect it. The second supplier only has to be real. Its quote costs an afternoon of calls and a week of waiting.
The gap also compounds. Take a 6% rise at three renewals in a row and the price ends up about 19% above where it started, and nobody has looked at it.
A sole-source label is a claim about the market. Before you renew on it, find out when someone last checked.
A true sole source still has a price you can test. Compare it with what the supplier charged you three years ago and with its own list price. If it sells to the US government, its schedule prices are often public on GSA Advantage. One of those numbers belongs in your first email.
Date every label before the renewal
Pull every contract marked sole source and sort the list by spend. For the top ten, find out who wrote the justification and in what year. Anything older than the last renewal goes back to the requester with one question. Who else could do this now?
Then ask a second supplier to quote on the largest one, even if you expect to stay. We would do this 90 days before the notice date, while the incumbent still wants the renewal and has time to answer. Keep the answers in the contract record with the date, so the next renewal starts from them.
Some labels will survive. A patent holds. So does an OEM part for a machine you own. Those contracts still have term, service levels and payment to negotiate, and the supplier knows it.
Where the second quote comes from
Re-sourcing is one of the jobs Sourcing was built for. When an incumbent's contract ends within a quarter, Whispor can find current, approved and new suppliers, collect sealed quotes and negotiate with the finalists one to one. Your team still makes the award.
Give Whispor the renewal as a goal, and nothing starts until you approve the plan. We would put a market test in that plan, and the old justification on your team's side of it. We think a sole-source label without a date on it is a price you agreed to without looking.
The Whispor team
Related: Suppliers price your switching cost, not your spend. · By the time the requisition reaches procurement, the negotiation is over · The price-increase letter is a negotiation. Most teams file it as paperwork.